Copy
View this email in your browser
Date of release: 17 August 2020
OUTCOME OF MATTERS CONSIDERED BY THE TRIBUNAL 
Type of matter Parties involved Commission's recommendation to the Tribunal Tribunal decision
Consent Agreement Commission And Ramsin Industrial Supplies CC t/a Fire Unlimited Confirm as an order Confirmed as an order
Consent Agreement Commission And Kalundu Trading (Pty) Ltd Confirm as an order Confirmed as an order
Consent Agreement Commission and Oil and More General Trading CC Confirm as an order Confirmed as an order
Durban-based fire equipment supplier admits to collusive tendering in Old Mutual, Tiger Brands tenders – agrees to pay fine
 
A Durban-based provider of fire protection services admits to collusive tendering in relation to tenders issued by Old Mutual and Tiger Brands respectively in 2016.
 
Ramsin lndustrial Supplies CC, trading as Fire Unlimited (Fire Unlimited), admits that it contravened section 4(1)(b)(iii) of the Competition Act (the Act) and agrees to pay an administrative penalty (a fine) of R59 660.05 (fifty-nine thousand six hundred and sixty Rand and five cents).
 
This forms part of a consent agreement between the Competition Commission (the Commission) and Fire Unlimited, which has been confirmed as an order of the Tribunal.
 
In terms of the consent agreement Fire Unlimited agrees to, among others:
  • refrain from engaging in any anti-competitive conduct in contravention of the Act in future;
  • develop, implement and monitor a competition law compliance programme as part of its corporate governance policy to ensure that all employees, members and management do not engage in future contraventions of the Act; and
  • commit itself to competitive practices.
 
Background
 
In July 2017, the Commission launched an investigation into the Automatic Sprinkler Inspection Bureau (ASIB), and all sprinkler installers registered with it.
 
Investigators found information indicating that Fire Unlimited and Eagle Fire Control CC may have entered into an agreement and/or engaged in a concerted practice to collude when bidding for tenders for the supply of automatic fire sprinklers. Further investigation by the Commission revealed the following:
 
  • On 23 January 2016, Fire Unlimited provided Eagle Fire with a cover quote for the supply and installation of fire equipment at Old Mutual properties;
  • On 24 March 2016, Fire Unlimited provided Eagle Fire with a cover quote for the replacement of sprinkler heads at Tiger Brand buildings; and that
  • This conduct amounts to collusive tendering in contravention of section 4(1)(b)(iii) of the Act.
Gauteng trader in alternators and starter motors guilty of
dividing markets, 
 fined R458K
 
A Gauteng company that trades in alternators, starter motors and associated spare parts has admitted to contravening section 4(1)(b)(ii) of the Competition Act (i.e. dividing markets) and agrees to pay a fine of R458 979.52 (four hundred and fifty-eight thousand, nine hundred and seventy-nine Rand and fifty-two cents).
 
This forms part of the terms of a consent agreement between the Commission and Kalundu Trading (Pty) Ltd. The Tribunal has confirmed the consent agreement as an order.
 
In addition to the admission and the payment of a fine, Kalundu also agrees, among others, to refrain from engaging in prohibited conduct in future and to implement and monitor a competition law compliance programme.
 
Background
 
In March 2019, the Commission received a complaint against Kalundu and POS Services Holland (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd (POS), a starter and alternator importer & exporter also based in Gauteng.
 
The allegations against the two companies were that they had entered into an agreement and/or engaged in a concerted practice to divide markets by allocating customers in the market for the supply of alternators and starter motors.
 
The Commission’s investigation found that the owners of both companies had indeed entered into an agreement to allocate customers towards the end of 2006, subsequent to POS entering the South African market. Among others, the Commission found:
 
  • The company owners agreed that Kalundu would purchase starter motors and alternators exclusively from POS to on-sell to wholesalers, on condition that POS not approach Kalundu’s existing and future customers of starter motors and alternators in the country;
  • Kalundu’s customer list, which POS was precluded from approaching, initially contained the names of about eight companies in 2007. By August 2018, the list contained about 200 customers, including the well-known South African retail store, Midas; and
  • Around August 2018, POS approached Midas to market and sell its starter motors and alternators. Kalundu instructed its lawyer to issue a letter to POS, demanding that POS desist from poaching its customers in compliance with their agreement.
Cape restaurant supplier admits to excessive pricing of nitrile gloves during Covid-19 pandemic – agrees to donate to Solidarity Fund
 
Oil and More General Trading CC (O&M), a Cape Town food distributor and restaurant supplier, admits to excessive pricing of nitrile gloves during March and April 2020 in contravention of the Act and the Consumer Protection Regulations (the Regulations).
 
Nitrile gloves fall under the category of “medical and hygiene supplies” in the Regulations.
 
In its consent agreement with the Commission, confirmed as an order of the Tribunal, O&M agrees to donate R18 361.51 to the Solidarity Fund. In addition, O&M agrees to:
 
  • Immediately stop the excessive pricing conduct as described in the consent agreement;
  • Immediately reduce its gross profit margin on nitrile gloves to and agreed maximum percentage for the duration of the state of disaster;
  • Implement and submit proof of a competition law compliance programme (incorporating corporate governance) to prevent future contraventions; and
  • Circulate the summarised consent agreement to management and staff.
 
In April 2020, the Commission received a complaint against O&M for the alleged inflated pricing of nitrile blue disposable gloves (nitrile gloves) between March and April 2020.
 
The Commission investigated and concluded that O&M’s gross profit margin during March and April 2020, in respect of nitrile gloves sold, amounts to a contravention of section 8(1)(a) of the Act (i.e. excessive pricing) read together with regulation 4 of the Regulations.
 
The Commission found that the pandemic gave market power to O&M in the market for the supply of food products and consumables to the hospitality industry in the City of Cape Town.
 
Issued by:

Gillian de Gouveia, Communications Officer
On behalf of the Competition Tribunal of South Africa
Tel: +27 (0) 12 394 1383
Cell: +27 (0) 82 410 1195
E-Mail: GillianD@comptrib.co.za
Twitter: @comptrib
Twitter
Website
Our mailing address is:
ctsa@comptrib.co.za

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.